Sin City
Directors:
Robert Rodriguez, Quentin Tarantino & Frank Miller
Stars:
Bruce Willis, Jessica Alba, Nick Stahl, Powers Boothe, Michael
Madsen, Mickey Rourke, Jaime King, Carla Guigino, Elijah Wood, Rutger
Hauer, Clive Owen, Rosario Dawson, Benico Del Toro, Brittany Murphy,
Devon Aoki, Michael Clarke Duncan, Alexis Bledel, Mary Shelton,Josh
Harnett & Frank Miller
Running Time:
124 mins
Release:
3rd
June 2005.
Sin City is based on Frank Miller's comic book noir series of the
same name and this film is made up of the graphic novels/stories: The
Hard Goodbye, The Big Fat Kill, That Yellow Bastard & The
Customer is always right which book ends the film. Not going to lie I
re-watched this film because Sin City 2: A Dame to Kill for is out
this coming August and I have not seen this film in years and I
wanted to revisit it. Sin City covers multiple stories of some of the
denizens of Basin City.
The Hard Goodbye focuses on Marv (Rourke) a large muscular thug who's
somewhat of a loner, Goldie (King) gives him the best night of his
life, when Marv awakes he find's Goldie dead in bed next to him. He
loved Goldie, she meant more to him than anything and now she's dead,
he's gonna kill his way to the top to get her killer, the silent
cannibalistic freak Kevin (Wood).
The Big Fat Kill focuses on Dwight (Owen) a hitman who's out to make
a hit on Jackie 'Boy' Rafferty (Toro) who's out for a woman's blood.
Dwight Kills him in Old Town which is run by his old flame Gail
(Dawson), after the hit they find out he was a hero cop and killing
a cop in Old Town breaks the truce between the mob and police and the
Old Town Girls, which was the Girls are the law in their part of town
and now they're coming for revenge.
That Yellow Bastard is about a good, clean honest cop called John
Hartigan (Willis) who's near retirement and has a dodgy ticker. Him
and his partner Bob (Madsen) go after a child rapist and killer Roark
Jr (Stahl) who's taken a little girl called Nancy Callahan. Hartigan
can't let him get away with it and kill again, Hartigan gets his man
and shoots off his ear, hand and the parts they make him a man and
just about to end him, Bob shoots him in the back, Hartigan survives
and goes into hospital and Roark's father Senator Roark (Boothe) pays
good money to fix him up to get revenge on him and make him to be a
child rapist, Nancy writes to him every week that he is inside prison
as he saved her, this carries on for 8 years she writes under a
different name so Roark can't find her. Then the letters stop and
Hartigan receives a letter with a severed finger and fears the worst
so he pleads guilty to be let out on bail to find and protect Nancy
(Alba) who's a daughter to him but Roark Jr is after her too, to
continue where he left off.
As there's a lot of actors in this i'll go through it story by story.
The Big Fat Kill first, That Yellow Bastard second and finally The
Hard Goodbye as that's my absolute favourite of the three.
Clive Owen is a british actor and being honest I could not make out
if it was an American accent or a British accent he was doing, though
I should say it did not have any effect on how I felt about his
performance in the film which is really good. Dwight is a hitman, a
wanted hitman who is a finger print away from going to the chamber,
so he has a new face (if you have read A Dame to Kill for and or see
the upcoming Sin City film you'll see/know why). He's very methodic
and plans his next move in every situation throughout the film He's
also very charismatic and intelligent and takes risks. I really love
the scene where he is in the car talking with the dead Jackie Boy
it's brilliant and has to be seen to be believed it's also darkly
funny, he has also has a penchant of wearing red converse trainers
and classic muscle cars.
Rosario Dawson is Gail she runs Old Town, she is the Girls leader and
you may have guessed that the Girls are prostitutes. She's Dwight ex
and does not like the fact that he bought the trouble to him but
helps him regardless as she still loves him, she's tough as nails
and as Dwight remarks she is his 'warrior woman' . Being honest I
have not seen Dawson in much aside Percy Jackson and The Lightning
Thief and Seven Pounds, this was made a few years before then, She
also features in The Hard Goodbye and she'll be reprising her role in
A Dame to Kill For. She's great in the role of Gail and when I read
the graphic novel I see Dawson. She also dresses very provocatively
Del Toro plays Jackie 'Boy' Rafferty a hero cop, in Basin City. He's
a woman beater and a drunk. He looks very dishevelled and his
language is slurred and Del Toro is perfect in the role as the dirty
cop who does not seem to be a cop at all. He is a brute and has a
really dark sense of humour like I mentioned before I love the scene
when he's in the car with Dwight and their first encounter In the
bathroom where Jackie makes the mistake of not flushing.
Now this brings me to two of the big characters in this story who
have unfortunately passed away way too soon; Michael Clarke Duncan as
Manute and Brittany Murphy as Shellie.
Manute is a henchman to an unnamed boss, as Michael Clarke Duncan was
of a very large man and was very imposing and was a very gentle and
kind man who had a knack for playing villains but also stole the show
as John Coffey in The Green Mile he was absolutely brilliant actor
and he was perfect as Manute is a man of few words but very
intelligent as is dressed like a chauffeur and is perfect in the role
of Manute. The character will be played by Dennis Haysbert in a Dame
to Kill for as it's set before the Big Fat Kill.
Shellie is a bar maid at Kadie's the strip bar where Marv, Hartigan
and Dwight visit in their stories and is a landmark in Basin City so
Shellie features in all three stories the biggest being in this one.
She was Jackie Boy's squeeze at one point till he beat her and she
left him for Dwight. Being honest I have not seen Murphy in much as
this is the most I have seen her act and she's brilliant in the role
as Shellie throughout despite not having much screen-time, she's had
enough of being smacked around by Jackie and his goons. She is
incredibly beautiful actress also has a great lovely sweet voice too,
it's unfortunate that she died at the age of 32 a few years ago she's
a brilliant actress, she'll be sorely missed.
It's very sad in some part watching this film knowing these two
amazing actors have died, it's very haunting.
Devon Aoki plays Miho or as Dwight calls her 'Deadly Little Miho' she
does not have a single line in this film so she has to emote using
her body language and facial expressions, she does not express much
as she's a silent bad ass just like she is in the comic book. She's
one of Gail's girls but she's not a prostitute, she's a protector and
a guardian watching over Old Town. She has some terrific action
scenes too. In a Dame to Kill For she'll be played by Jamie Chung, as
Aoki wants to focus on her family, it would be interesting to see how
Chung is in the role.
Bruce Willis plays John Hartigan, a detective in Basin City Police
with a 30 year service and a dodgy ticker. He's one of the few good
cops, he is selfless, cynical and gruff and calls himself 'stupid old
man' he can withstand a lot of pain. Hartigan has not featured in
many of the Sin City Stories though Frank Miller has said that he
plans to write a story set before That Yellow Bastard. Willis is
brilliant in the role, at the time of filming Hartigan was
considerably older than himself but with A Dame To Kill this year he
is much closer to his age. He forms a father figure bond with Nancy
and see's her as his own daughter. Nancy has in love with Hartigan as
he saved her. He has a cross scar on his forehead and wears a suit,
tie and trench coat and his cannon is his magnum. I have to say this
is my absolute favourite role that Willis has done in my opinion he's
perfect as Hartigan and he'll be appearing in Nancy's story and
Marv's Just Another Saturday Night.
Jessica Alba get's a lot of flack for her acting, she's mostly known
for her very beautiful look therefore discredit her as an actress,
and after seeing her in a few films I have to say she is pretty good
actress, she has done a lot of great films and is going from strength
to strength. Nancy is one her earliest roles and she's perfect in the
role as Nancy Callahan. She remembers Hartigan very well and
constantly writes to him and over the years she has fallen in love
with him, something of which Hartigan is against at first. She's a
very strong woman and intelligent but needs Hartigan to protect her,
we'll see how different she is In the sequel. Like others she pops up
in other stories most notably Marv's as he has a crush on her.
There's been some complaints about the difference between Nancy in
the film and in the graphic novel as she's a dancer at Kadie's Bar,
and you may know already what they are but personally I am not that
bothered by it to be honest.
I've only seen Nick Stahl in one film and that one film is Terminator
3: Rise of The Machines and I know he was in the American series
Carnivale. He was pretty good in Terminator 3 for what it's worth but
he's far much better in this as Roark Jr also known as The Yellow
Bastard, you'll have to see the film or read the graphic novel to
know why but you can properly guess what I mean. He's a real evil
sadistic creep in this film and looks it to both before and after his
'transformation' it's a pity I have not seen him in many films, but I
have to say he has one of my favourite lines in this film 'You can't
even lift that cannon' I love that line.
Michael Madsen is a regular collaborator with Tarantino so it was not
a complete surprise he was in this, he plays Bob, Hartigan’s
partner and a corrupt cop who betrays Hartigan for the Roark family.
He has a great chemistry with Hartigan as they have meant to be
partners for years and despite his betrayal Hartigan still gets on
with him. It's a great little role.
In a small but pivotal role in the Sin City mythos is Senator Rourke
the main villain in Sin City, he runs Basin City and he's the father
to Roarke Junior, Boothe plays him exceedingly well. I have only
seen Boothe in Southern Comfort, if you have not seen it you need to
see it, it's awesome. He's incredibly dastardly,corrupt and evil and
untouchable and hopes that his one and only son Roark Jr that will
become President. He only features in one scene; the hospital scene
and he steals the whole scene I love how evil his eyes looked too, he
looked really menacing.
I have to say casting Mickey Rourke as Marv is perfect, they could of
not picked a better actor to play him, in film he's of a slightly
smaller build but still a big guy. Marv is a legend in Basin City, he
has a hulking build, a heavily scarred face, brilliant fighting
skills and highly intellectual but mostly uses his brute strength
though he is no thug. He's loyal, chivalrous, kind does not kill
anyone who don't deserve it though never feels guilty about killing
paid hit men, he has ethics and a moral code and don't like 'men
roughing up dames'. He really enjoys slowly killing people that truly
deserve it in the most horrific fashion.
He has an unknown mental condition that makes him confused and is
afraid of going to far and becoming a maniac, he uses med's to keep
his condition under control.
He has a platonic relationship with Nancy whom he see's himself as
her guardian angel and his parole officer Lucille (Guigino), they
adore Marv and will do anything they can for him.
He also has a soft calm voice, a wry laconic sense of humour and a
dark one and a penchant for 'damn fine coats' and old fashioned
muscle cars, he see's newer ones looking like electronic razors and
has a handgun called 'Gladys' which he has since he was a young man
and named it after one of his favourite teachers. He really does
bring the character to life and is the best depiction of a comic book
character I have ever seen he nails it and I cannot wait to see him
again in a Dame to Kill For. I love every single scene he is in.
I particularly love the scene with his mother I am not going to spoil
it for you but it's endearing, tender and quite funny. He also pops
up in The Kadie's Bar scene in The Hard Goodbye, I love the
expression on his face when he see's Nancy run to Hartigan. Also
Dwight who is Marv's friend, gives the perfect monologue to Marv. You
can't help but the love the guy and root for him. It's one of
Rourke's finest for sure.
Jaimie King plays Goldie, the only woman who shows Marv physical
affection and offered herself in return for protection, Marv loves
her. Her death is the start of his campaign to find her killer. She
also plays her twin sister Wendy who's also a prostitute and a
leader in Old Town who initially thinks Marv killer her sister and
the other prostitutes, Marv see's her as the rougher twin, to say
anymore would spoil it for you. I have not seen Jaime King in
anything else but she is great in the role(s).
Before he played the sympathetic serial killer Frank, he played Kevin
a nutty religious mute cannibalistic killer who's not in the least
sympathetic at all, it's a silent role for Wood, he does not express
much emotion as he is evil and only smiles when he knows he has
inflicted pain or horrifically mentally scarred one of his victims,
he's a completely evil little bastard who's incredibly quick and
quiet and has a penchant for wearing circular glasses and sweaters.
The fight scenes between him and Marv are fantastic and being as this
was made a few years after Lord of The Rings it must of shocked some
and I have to say Elijah Wood is perfect for playing creepy serial
killers.
Rutger Hauer plays Cardinal Roark, Senator Roark's brother. Cardinal
got his brother that position in power, just like his brother he is
corrupt and has a heavy influence in politics He also joins in
Kevin's sick activities believing that when they eat the prostitutes
flesh that it'll bring him and Kevin closer to god. He's the only
person Kevin speaks to and apparently he has a voice like an Angel.
Hauer has only a little role in the film but it's a fantastic role
and he is completely chilling but calm.
Carla Guigino who's collaborated with Rodriguez before in the past
with the Spy Kids films, this is her most recent collaboration with
Rodriguez though she has done one other iconic comic book film The
Watchmen. She plays Lucille who is Marv's parole officer, she also
featured in That Yellow Bastard. She has a more prominent role in
this. She is a lesbian and her girlfriend supplies her with
antibiotics to keep Marv's condition under control as she cares for
Marv and Marv see's her a friend and their meeting we see in this is
brilliant, her girlfriend tried to analyse Marv but got scared. She's
a fantastic actress that we simply don't see enough of.
Also Josh Harnett plays the Salesman, Mary Shelton plays The Customer
in The Customer is Always Right which the film opens too and is
bookended with the Salesman meeting Becky played Alexis Bledel who
has a small role in The Hard Goodbye and The Big Fat Kill. I haven't
commented on the acting as they are only small roles. Also watch out
for Frank Miller's cameo in The Hard Goodbye !.
Robert Rodriguez, Graeme Revell and John Debney are responsible for
the absolutely nigh on perfect soundtrack it suits the neo noir
atmosphere of the film completely once you've seen the film you'll
want the soundtrack it's an absolutely iconic soundtrack, it's eerie,
beautiful, thrilling, haunting and incredibly exciting.
This film is filmed digitally and there was only three sets made;
Kadie's Bar, Shellie's apartment and The Hospital Corridor everything
else was done on green screen, to me most of it looked real which is
a feat in itself. I should also note this film is filmed in almost
all black and white just like the comic book and it's shot to panel
perfect. There's a few splashes of colour in certain scenes and blood
splatter, clothing, and people's eyes to make them piercing and stand
out which is a terrific effect. Visually it looks stunning and
arresting in every single sense especially on Blu-Ray.
This is the best comic book adaptation I have ever seen and Rodriguez
best film in my opinion, Miller supervised the film and Tarantino
directed one scene though I am not sure which one exactly. They've
done a top up job bringing Basin City to life. It's very thematic
too; corruption, love, lust murder, oaths, loyalty,death, justice,
revenge & morality.
You'll need a strong stomach to watch this it's pretty gory but also
darkly comic.
It's an onslaught both visually and audibly. Sin City comes at the
screen at 80mph and does not let up for a second it's relentless and
if it's your first trip to Basin City your in for a real treat. I for
one need to catch up and get the graphic novels and return to the
world of Sin City onscreen in August which I cannot wait for.